puck/lix
0
0
Fork 0
forked from lix-project/lix
Code Pull requests Activity

doc/glossary: Define package and package attribute set

Browse source 
A small step towards https://github.com/NixOS/nix/issues/6507

I believe this incomplete definition is one that can be agreed on.
It would be nice to define more, but considering that the issue
also proposes changes to the design, I believe we should hold off
on those.

As for the wording, we're dealing with some very general and vague
terms, that have to be treated with exactly the right amount of
vagueness to be effective.

I start out with a fairly abstract definition of package.
1. to establish a baseline so we know what we're talking about
2. so that we can go in and clarify that we have an extra, Nix-specific
   definition.

"Software" is notoriously ill-defined, so it makes a great qualifier
for package, which we don't really want to pin down either, because
that would just get us lost in discussion.
We can come back to this after we've done 6057 and a few years in a
desert cave.

Then comes the "package attribute set" definition.
I can already hear Valentin say "That's not even Nix's responsibility!"
and on some days I might even agree.
However, in our current reality, we have `nix-env`, `nix-build` and
`nix profile`, which query the `outputName` attribute - among others -
which just don't exist in the derivation.

For those who can't believe what they're reading:

    $ nix-build --expr 'with import ./. {}; bind // {outputName = "lib";}' --no-out-link
    this path will be fetched (1.16 MiB download, 3.72 MiB unpacked):
      /nix/store/rfk6klfx3z972gavxlw6iypnj6j806ma-bind-9.18.21-lib
    copying path '/nix/store/rfk6klfx3z972gavxlw6iypnj6j806ma-bind-9.18.21-lib' from 'https://cache.nixos.org'...
    /nix/store/rfk6klfx3z972gavxlw6iypnj6j806ma-bind-9.18.21-lib

and let me tell you that bind is not a library.

So anyway, that's also proof of why calling this a "derivation attrset" would be wrong, despite the type attribute.
This commit is contained in:
Robert Hensing 2024-01-13 20:00:06 +01:00
parent cbd5553d57
commit 7e5fa5c25c
1 changed files with 15 additions and 0 deletions
Show stats Download patch file Download diff file Expand all files Collapse all files

15
doc/manual/src/glossary.md
View file

@ -271,6 +271,21 @@
The epsilon symbol. In the context of a package, this means the version is empty. More precisely, the derivation does not have a version attribute. The epsilon symbol. In the context of a package, this means the version is empty. More precisely, the derivation does not have a version attribute.
- [package]{#package}
1. A software package; typically a collection of programs, files and data.
2. A [package attribute set].
- [package attribute set]{#package-attribute-set}
An [attribute set] containing the attribute `type = "derivation";` (derivation for historical reasons), as well as other attributes, such as
- attributes that refer to the files of a [package], typically in the form of [derivation outputs](#output),
- attributes that declare something about how the package is supposed to be installed or used,
- other metadata or arbitrary attributes.
[package attribute set]: #package-attribute-set
- [string interpolation]{#gloss-string-interpolation} - [string interpolation]{#gloss-string-interpolation}
Expanding expressions enclosed in `${ }` within a [string], [path], or [attribute name]. Expanding expressions enclosed in `${ }` within a [string], [path], or [attribute name].